Pros and Cons of Going to Trial in Personal Injury Cases

If you’re recovering from an accident, you may face a crucial decision: Should you settle your case or proceed to trial? Both options come with distinct advantages and disadvantages. A settlement offer is a quicker and less stressful resolution, while going to trial might result in a higher award but involves more risk and uncertainty. Learn about the pros and cons of a jury trial and why you should consider it.

At Gatti, Keltner, Bienvenu & Montesi, PLC, our personal injury lawyers can help you make this decision and handle all the necessary legal work, regardless of your chosen approach. We’ll evaluate your case, discuss the pros and cons of each approach, and ensure you understand your options. With our guidance, you can make the best choice for your recovery and future. You’ll find more information on the pros and cons of taking a personal injury case to trial below.

Benefits of Settling a Personal Injury Case

Settling a personal injury case can offer several advantages, making it an attractive option for many accident victims. Here are some potential benefits of choosing to settle your case:

• Faster Resolution: Settling a case typically takes less time consuming than going to trial. Trials can take a long time, sometimes dragging on for months or even years. A settlement can provide you with compensation much sooner, allowing you to cover your expenses and move on with your life.
• Lower Costs: Trials can be expensive due to legal fees, court costs, and other expenses. Settling a case often reduces these costs significantly, leaving you with more settlement money to cover your medical bills and other fees.
• Less Stress: The trial process can be stressful and emotionally draining. Settling a case can alleviate the anxiety and uncertainty of a courtroom battle. You can avoid the pressure of testifying and the stress of waiting for a jury’s informed decision.
• Certainty of Outcome: When you settle, you know exactly what compensation you will receive. In contrast, going to trial involves uncertainty, as the outcome is in a judge’s or jury’s hands. Settling provides a guaranteed result, which can be particularly reassuring when dealing with financial and medical challenges.
• Privacy: Settlements are typically private, whereas trial proceedings are public records. By settling, you can keep the details of your case confidential, protecting your privacy and avoiding public scrutiny.
• Control Over the Process: Settling allows both parties to negotiate terms and reach a mutually agreeable resolution. This collaborative process can lead to more satisfactory outcomes than a trial, where the decision is out of your hands.
• Reduced Risk: Trials have inherent risks, including possibly losing the case or receiving less compensation than expected. Settling minimizes these risks by providing you with guaranteed compensation without the gamble of a trial.

Benefits of Taking an Injury Case to Trial

Although there are cons to it, there are also pros a jury trial can offer. Here are some potential benefits of taking a personal injury case to court:

• Potential for Higher Compensation: One of the most significant benefits of going to trial is the possibility of receiving a higher compensation award. Juries sometimes award substantial amounts for your losses, including compensation for your pain and suffering. A trial award might be more than you could achieve through a settlement.
• Full Disclosure of Evidence: Trials require both sides to present all their evidence. This means you can compel the other party to disclose information they might withhold during settlement negotiations. Full disclosure can strengthen your case and increase your chances of a favorable outcome.
• Accountability: Going to trial can hold the responsible party publicly accountable for their actions. This can be particularly important when negligence or misconduct leads to injuries. A trial can serve as a powerful statement and may deter future negligent behavior by the defendant.
• Validation and Justice: For many victims, the trial process provides a sense of validation and justice. Having your day in court and presenting your case to a jury can be an empowering experience. It allows you to tell your story and seek justice openly.
• Legal Precedent: Trials can set legal precedents that may benefit others in similar situations. Your case could contribute to shaping the law and improving protections for future accident victims.
• Negotiation Leverage: The willingness to go to trial can sometimes improve your position in settlement negotiations. Knowing that you are prepared to take the case to court can pressure the other party to offer a more favorable settlement to avoid the risks and costs of a trial.

Making the Decision to Go to Trial for a Personal Injury Lawsuit

It’s vital to talk to a lawyer and have them thoroughly review the pros and cons of going to a jury trial with your case. Your lawyer can review the available evidence, catalog your losses, and look at existing legal precedents to see whether going to trial is worth the potential risk.

If you choose to pursue a settlement, working with an experienced attorney is still vital. They can help you maximize your potential compensation and prepare your case for trial. You might get a more favorable settlement by demonstrating that you’re ready to take your case to court if necessary.

Finally, you’ll need a lawyer’s help to take your case to court. Civil trials involve complex deadlines, rules, and procedures. A personal injury attorney can handle your legal work and see that everything goes smoothly. They can also help you make a solid case for a judge or jury, increasing your chances of recovering the money you need to rebuild your life.

Deadline to File a Personal Injury Lawsuit in Tennessee

If you want to take your case to court, you must file a lawsuit within the required deadline. Tennessee law says you must file a personal injury lawsuit within one year of when you sustained your injuries. In some cases, such as claims involving government agencies, you might have an even shorter window to act. Contact an experienced Memphis personal injury attorney immediately after an accident to protect your legal rights and avoid any deadline issues with your case.

With years of experience in handling similar notable cases, we can provide our insights and help you decide the right course of action. Whether you accept an insurance settlement or take your case to trial, our attorneys at Gatti, Keltner, Bienvenu & Montesi, PLC can protect your rights and help you seek fair compensation for your injuries. Contact our law firm at (901) 526-2126 or through our online form for a free consultation.

Related Posts:

Winning Strategies for Personal Injury Mediation

Personal Injury Settlement Taxes Overview

Personal Injury Deposition Preparation Guide